Both work. The choice comes down to whether you want to maintain the record yourself or have it maintained for you.
A spreadsheet is free and yours
No subscription, no lock-in, and you can compute anything you like. The cost is that every wear must be logged by hand.
The logging is what decides it
Wear counts are the valuable data and the tedious part. Whichever option you will actually keep updated is the right one.
Start with a spreadsheet
It costs nothing to find out whether you will maintain a record at all before committing to anything.
How they compare
How they compare
- Spreadsheet: free, flexible, fully yours, entirely manual
- Spreadsheet: best for cost per wear analysis you define yourself
- App: faster logging, visual, outfit planning built in
- App: subscription, and your data lives in someone else’s system
- Either: useless if you do not keep it current